Health Care Employer Alert: New FTC Rule May Impact Non-Competes

On April 23, 2024, the Federal Trade Commission (FTC), consistent with its January 2023 proposed rule, voted 3-2 for a nationwide ban against non-compete clauses in employment agreements with certain limited exceptions. These provisions, common in employment contracts, including many of those created to meet the needs of the health care sector, are intended to prevent employees from either leaving the organization or accepting a position with a competitor. Under the new rule, such clauses will be prohibited except for senior executives in policy-making roles and earning more than $151,164 per year, and those already in effect will no longer be enforceable.

Almost immediately after publication of the new rule, the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and other business groups filed suit against the agency. The probability is high that this litigation will take years to resolve and could potentially end up before the U.S. Supreme Court. Although Section 6(g) of the Federal Trade Commission Act gives FTC rule-making authority, the new rule represents such a change from the status quo that it might be vulnerable under the Supreme Court’s “major question” doctrine, which is a presumption that Congress would not grant an administrative agency the power to decide issues of major national importance without an express delegation of authority.

While its fate is uncertain, here are some of the implications the new rule could have for the health care sector:

Enforceability
The new rule is effective August 21, 2024 in all states and the District of Columbia. It preempts conflicting state laws to the extent they conflict with the rule. Some states, such as Virginia, however, have already issued laws pertaining to non-competition provisions. Presumably, the FTC would have to enforce the new rule, although its mere existence is likely to discourage employers from using non-competition provisions in the future or enforcing existing provisions.

Applicability
As the FTC lacks jurisdiction over nonprofits, the nation’s many not-for-profit hospitals may remain able to impose non-compete clauses on their employees., Many health systems have for-profit subsidiaries or joint ventures that may be within the FTC’s reach, however.

Management Services Organizations (MSOs)
MSOs are entities that, for a fee, provide an array of business services to entities that, in certain states, can be lawfully owned only by licensed health care professionals, such as medical practices. Through an MSO, lay investors, often through private equity funds, can profit from revenues generated by medical practices without violating the corporate practice of medicine laws found in most states. Such a so-called “friendly PC” arrangement also allows the practice (the PC, or professional corporation) to benefit from the business acumen of the MSO. These arrangements often rely on physician non-compete agreements to ensure the group that the MSO contracts with will remain viable. Under the new rule, however, physicians employed in a practice contracted to the MSO could potentially accept a position from a nearby competing practice, and in doing so quite possibly deny the business opportunities that attracted the MSO to serve the practice in the first place.

Mergers and Acquisitions
Similar scenarios arise concerning health care M&A activity: as it is likely a medical staff enhances a particular target’s attractiveness, it is fair to question whether instability in such a key asset could chill the ardor of a possible purchaser. A deal may appear less attractive or even too risky altogether if an acquiring entity cannot be sure the acquired entity will be able to legally enforce its non-compete clauses. It is worth noting, however, that the new rule will not prevent using a non-competition provision with the seller in connection with the sale of a medical practice or other business where the parties are subject to the new rule.

Next Steps
The uncertainty created by the promulgation of such a sweeping new rule could have profound financial and employment impact, not only in health care but across the economy. Providers and others in the health care sector should act now to evaluate the impact of the new rule on existing agreements and pending transactions. While the litigation may take some time to bring certainty, the new rule is effective August 21, 2024, which is 120 days after April 23, unless judicial intervention forces a postponement.

A printed version of this information can be found here.

Attorneys and practice areas related to this topic include:

Jonathan M. Joseph

Joseph P. McMenamin

Health Care


This item has been provided as an informational service and does not constitute legal counsel or advice, which can only be rendered in the context of specific factual situations. If a legal issue should arise, please contact an attorney listed or retain the assistance of other competent legal counsel. Case results depend on a variety of factors unique to each case and results do not guarantee or predict a similar result in any future case undertaken.